Geopolitical Rivalries and the Future of Multilateralism
Context:
- 3 major international summits — the East Asia Summit (EAS) in Manila, APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting in Shenzhen and G20 Summit in Miami — will bring global leaders together, as 2026 is coming to an end.
- These events are scheduled amid intensifying geopolitical rivalries, economic disruptions and weakening multilateral institutions.
- Hence, the central challenge is to preserve international cooperation in an increasingly fragmented, great-power-driven global order.
East Asia Summit (EAS) - Testing ASEAN Centrality:
- Geopolitical context:
- The EAS comprises ASEAN members and eight dialogue partners, including India, the US, China and Russia.
- The Philippines concludes its ASEAN chairmanship amid heightened tensions with China in the South China Sea, emerging as ASEAN's most vocal critic of Chinese maritime assertiveness.
- The unresolved Myanmar crisis highlights ASEAN's limited capacity to address internal political instability.
- Strategic significance and limitations:
- ASEAN centrality remains the organising principle of the EAS, providing a platform for dialogue among competing powers.
- However, ASEAN's influence over major powers remains limited, with its role largely confined to convening and facilitating discussions.
- Leadership participation:
- The US President's anticipated attendance would reinforce Washington's engagement, although his interest may be driven more by support for the Philippines than ASEAN.
- China is generally represented by its Premier rather than President Xi Jinping, while Russia has recently participated through Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov.
- The Indian PM's participation would reaffirm India's commitment to ASEAN centrality, particularly during the ASEAN-India Year of Maritime Cooperation.
- Possible Quad Summit on the sidelines:
- A meeting involving the leaders of India, the US, Japan and Australia could revive leadership-level momentum within the Quad.
- However, China's criticism of a possible Quad revival could intensify strategic exchanges at the EAS.
APEC Summit - Economic Competition and US-China Rivalry:
- APEC: It is an intergovernmental economic forum for 21 member economies around the Pacific Rim that promotes free trade, regional economic integration, and sustainable growth.
- China's strategic objectives:
- Hosting the APEC Summit in Shenzhen provides Beijing an opportunity to project its technological and economic ambitions.
- China is likely to counter international concerns regarding industrial overcapacity, economic coercion and excessive dependence on Chinese supply chains.
- Challenges to APEC's effectiveness: US-China competition over tariffs, technology restrictions and supply-chain security could undermine regional economic integration.
- Potential Trump-Xi and Trump-Xi-Putin engagements:
- These possible bilateral meetings could overshadow the formal proceedings.
- Agreements on tariffs, technology restrictions and trade imbalances could influence the global economic environment.
G20 Summit:
- Contestation over global governance: The challenge of the G20 Summit in Miami will extend beyond managing global economic issues to maintaining the credibility and inclusiveness of the institution itself.
- Changing priorities under the US presidency:
- The Trump administration seeks to narrow the agenda towards deregulation, energy costs, innovation and economic growth.
- This represents a departure from the emphasis on development, climate action and debt concerns under the Indonesian, Indian, Brazilian and South African presidencies.
- Great-power diplomacy and geopolitical tensions:
- Xi Jinping's attendance appears likely, while Putin's participation remains uncertain.
- A possible Trump-Putin meeting could influence negotiations over the Ukraine conflict.
- However, excluding Ukraine or European leaders from substantive negotiations would raise questions about legitimacy and undermine European security interests.
India's Strategic Stakes in the Three Summits:
- Strategic importance for India:
- EAS: Reinforces Act East Policy, ASEAN centrality and maritime cooperation.
- APEC: India is not a member but remains affected by regional economic and supply-chain developments.
- G20: Provides a platform to advance development priorities, energy security and the interests of emerging economies.
- Key opportunities:
- EAS can strengthen India's Indo-Pacific engagement and its MAHASAGAR
- G20 offers an opportunity to defend the priorities of the Global South, particularly development financing, energy security and inclusive growth.
- The EAS and G20 provide complementary platforms for advancing India’s foreign-policy and economic interests.
Challenges to Effective Multilateralism:
- Great-power rivalry: Strategic competition increasingly overrides collective interests.
- Institutional limitations: Multilateral forums struggle to translate dialogue into enforceable outcomes.
- Fragmentation of global trade: Protectionism, technological restrictions and supply-chain vulnerabilities threaten economic integration.
- Selective multilateralism: Major powers increasingly use international institutions to advance national priorities.
- Erosion of inclusiveness: Disputes over participation and representation undermine institutional legitimacy.
Way Forward:
- Reinvigorate multilateral institutions: Strengthen consensus-building and ensure equitable representation of developing countries.
- Promote strategic dialogue: Institutionalise communication among competing powers to prevent geopolitical tensions from escalating.
- Strengthen economic cooperation: Protect open trade, resilient supply chains and technology-sharing arrangements.
- Reaffirm ASEAN centrality: Preserve ASEAN-led platforms as important mechanisms for Indo-Pacific stability.
- Advance Global South priorities: Ensure development financing, climate justice, debt sustainability and energy security remain central to global governance.
Conclusion:
- The collective legacy of the EAS, APEC and G20 will depend not merely on negotiated declarations but on whether bilateral and trilateral power bargains reinforce or undermine multilateral cooperation.
- Although these institutions are increasingly constrained by great-power competition, they remain indispensable platforms for dialogue, diplomacy and collective problem-solving.