Mains Daily Question
Jan. 22, 2024

Q3. Discuss the factors that hinders effective grassroots democracy while suggesting the measures for a more robust local self governance system at village level.(10M, 150W)

Model Answer

Approach:

Introduction: Provide a concise definition or overview of Local Self Governance (LSG), emphasizing its decentralization of powers to grassroots-level local bodies.

Body: 

Heading 1: Discuss key challenges hindering the effectiveness of grassroots democracy in India.

Heading 2:  Propose specific measures to address each challenge.

Conclusion: Emphasize the need to address challenges and implement constructive measures to empower them as effective instruments of decentralized governance.

 

Answer: Local Self Governance (LSG) refers to the decentralization of powers and functions to local bodies at the grassroots level. Panchayati Raj Institutions and Urban Local Governments, as units of local government were granted constitutional status as the third tier of India’s federal democracy through the 73rd & 74th Amendment Act.

 

It aimed at fostering participatory democracy, empowering local communities, and addressing their specific needs but there are many issues which have rendered the 3rd tier of government in a state where it has more responsibility but less power and resources.  

 

Challenges hinder effective grassroots democracy in India:

  • Limited Financial Autonomy: Many PRIs face financial constraints, with limited revenue-generation capabilities. Dependence on higher levels of government for funds can compromise their autonomy, affecting their ability to address local needs independently.
  • Political Interference: Local elections often witness interference from higher political authorities, impacting their independence. This interference can lead to decisions that prioritize political considerations over the welfare of the local population.
  • Capacity and Skill Gaps: These institutions may lack the necessary human and technical resources for effective governance. Insufficient capacity and skill gaps among elected representatives and administrative staff can hinder the implementation of development plans and programs.
  • Social and Cultural Barriers: Deep-rooted social and cultural norms may limit the participation of certain groups, particularly women, in the decision-making process. Overcoming these barriers is crucial for ensuring inclusive and representative governance.

 

Measures to Overcome Challenges:

  • Financial Empowerment: Provide them with greater financial autonomy by enhancing revenue-generation mechanisms and ensuring a fair share of centrally allocated funds. This will enable them to implement development projects more effectively.
    • For example, Karnataka's devolution of land rights to Panchayats for revenue generation.
  • Capacity Building: Invest in capacity-building programs for their elected representatives and administrative staff. This includes training in governance, financial management, and the use of technology to enhance their effectiveness in local administration. 
    • For Example, Rajiv Gandhi National Institute of Panchayat Raj 
  • Legal and Institutional Reforms: Strengthen legal frameworks governing the PRIs to protect them from undue political interference. Establish mechanisms for transparent and accountable decision-making, ensuring that decisions are made in the best interest of the local community.
  • Community Awareness Programs: Conduct community awareness programs to educate the local population about the importance of their active involvement in local governance. This can enhance civic engagement and foster a sense of ownership and responsibility among citizens.

By addressing these challenges and implementing constructive measures, the PRIs can fulfill their potential as effective instruments of decentralized governance, promoting grassroots democracy and contributing to local development.

Subjects : Polity
Only Students can submit Answer.