Mains Daily Question
Oct. 27, 2023

Q2. Under the garb of advocating human and environmental rights, foreign funding NGOs have been adding fuel to India's internal security problems. Comment.(10M, 150W)

Model Answer

Approach to Answer:

Introduction:

Type 1: Mention about NGOs and their foreign funding.

Type 2: Give contextual introduction by mentioning recent government measures or legislation amendments regarding NGOs and foreign funding.

Body:

Heading 1:  Importance of foreign funding for NGOs

Heading 2: Ways in which foreign-funded NGOs can contribute to internal security problems

Conclusion: 

Type 1: can write about the measures taken by government to regulate foreign funding of NGOs.

Type 2: Can end with a way forward, explaining the balance needed to ensure that “just” NGOs continue to thrive.

 

Answer: Donor funds are the lifeline of NGOs, especially in developing countries. These NGOs play a vital role in social and economic upliftment, ensuring accountability of those in power or important positions, environmental conservation, ensuring rights of all etc. In the last few years, India has banned more than 15000 NGOs, registered under (FCRA), from receiving foreign funds.

 

Importance of foreign funding for NGOs

  • Financial Sustainability: Foreign funding provides NGOs with the necessary financial resources to sustain their operations, implement projects, and achieve their missions.
  • Expanded Reach: It enables NGOs to extend their reach and impact beyond local borders, addressing global issues and reaching communities that might not otherwise receive support.
  • Expertise and Knowledge Sharing: Foreign funding often comes with expertise, technical know-how, and best practices that NGOs can leverage to improve their programs and operations.
  • Advocacy and Awareness: International funding enables NGOs to raise awareness about global issues, advocate for policy changes, and influence decision-making at higher levels.
  • Emergency Response: Foreign funding can quickly mobilize resources for emergency relief efforts in response to natural disasters, conflicts, or health crises.

 

Foreign-funded NGOs can contribute to internal security problems in the following ways:

  • Funding Sources and Transparency: Lack of transparency about funding sources can raise suspicions about the motives behind NGO activities.
  • Diversion of Funds: There have been allegations of funds meant for developmental or charitable purposes being diverted to support other activities, including those with potential security implications.
  • Political Agendas: Some foreign-funded NGOs have been accused of promoting political agendas that are at odds with the national interest or that aim to destabilize certain regions or communities.
  • Anti-Development Stance: In some cases, foreign-funded NGOs have been seen as opposing development projects, particularly in sectors like infrastructure and industry.
  • Misuse of Protests: There have been instances where NGOs have exploited protests to create unrest or obstruct legitimate development projects.
  • Security Concerns in Conflict Zones: In conflict-affected areas, foreign-funded NGOs might inadvertently contribute to perpetuating conflicts or supporting groups with separatist or insurgent tendencies.

 

Measures taken by government to regulate foreign funding of NGOs

  • Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA): The FCRA is the primary legislation that governs the acceptance and utilization of foreign contributions by NGOs in India. It mandates NGOs to register under FCRA to receive foreign funds and puts restrictions on the use of these funds for specific activities.
  • Registration and Prior Approval: NGOs intending to receive foreign funding must register under FCRA or seek prior approval from the government. The registration is valid for five years and can be renewed if the NGO continues to meet the requirements.
  • Bank Accounts: NGOs are required to maintain a designated bank account for all foreign contributions and provide detailed information about the utilization of these funds.
  • Reporting and Transparency: Registered NGOs are required to submit annual reports detailing the inflow and utilization of foreign funds.
  • Usage Restrictions: The government places restrictions on the usage of foreign funds for activities like political activities, religious conversions, and activities that could affect India's sovereignty and integrity.
  • Blacklisting: NGOs that violate FCRA regulations or engage in activities contrary to the national interest can be blacklisted, leading to a ban on foreign funding.

 

Foreign funding plays a pivotal role in empowering NGOs to make meaningful contributions to society and address pressing challenges on a global scale. The Indian government has taken several measures to regulate foreign funding of NGOs in the country. These measures are designed to ensure that foreign funding is utilized for genuine social, developmental, and charitable purposes while preventing misuse or misappropriation of funds by NGOs.

Subjects : Polity
Only Students can submit Answer.