Mains Daily Question
Jan. 27, 2024

Q2. Discuss the challenges posed by China's growing influence in Bhutan to India's security interests. Suggest strategies to mitigate these challenges and strengthen India-Bhutan's strategic partnership.(10M, 150W)

Model Answer

Approach: 

Understanding and structuring the answer

Here are the keywords India Bhutan relationships and growing impact of China. Here look for the present threats and possible avenues that India has to mitigate that threat.

Introduction: Give brief importance of Bhutan w.r.t. India and link it with the growing aggression of China

Body

Heading 1: Challenges Posed by China's Growing Influence

Heading 2: Mitigating Strategies and Strengthening the Partnership

Conclusion: Conclude the answer with a progressive trajectory of India-Bhutan Diplomatic relations

 

Answer: Bhutan, nestled between India and China, is strategically crucial in the Himalayas. While India has traditionally been Bhutan's closest ally, China's growing influence in the region poses significant challenges to India's security interests. Understanding these challenges and crafting effective strategies to navigate them is critical for preserving the unique India-Bhutan partnership.

Challenges Posed by China's Growing Influence:

  1. Strategic Encirclement: China's infrastructure investments in Bhutan, including roads and hydropower projects, aim to create economic dependence and potentially facilitate military deployment closer to India's vulnerable Siliguri Corridor, the narrow landmass connecting its northeastern states.
  2. Border Disputes: China lays claim to over 270 sq km of Bhutanese territory, particularly the Doklam plateau, strategically located near the tri-junction with India. Any resolution without Indian involvement could undermine its strategic interests.
  3. Weakening Buffer State: A more China-dependent Bhutan could dilute its strategic autonomy and reduce its effectiveness as a buffer state against Chinese expansionism, impacting India's overall security posture.
  4. Limited Leverage: China's growing leverage over Bhutan could weaken India's ability to influence regional geopolitical dynamics, potentially forcing it to accommodate Chinese interests in other areas.

Mitigating Strategies and Strengthening the Partnership:

  1. Economic Re-engagement: India must counter China's economic influence by increasing its own investments in Bhutan's infrastructure development, renewable energy projects, and digital connectivity, all while respecting Bhutan's environmental sensitivity. India's recent announcement of a $2 billion aid package for Bhutan demonstrates its commitment to maintaining economic primacy.
  2. Border Resolution: Collaborative efforts to resolve the Doklam standoff and other disputed border areas through peaceful negotiations and multilateral forums like SAARC, showcasing India's commitment to Bhutan's territorial integrity.
  3. Enhanced Security Cooperation: Deepening military-to-military cooperation through joint exercises, intelligence sharing, and capacity building for the Royal Bhutan Army can bolster Bhutan's self-defence capabilities and deter further Chinese incursions.
  4. Soft Power and Cultural Ties: India can leverage its historical, cultural, and linguistic ties with Bhutan through increased cultural exchanges, scholarships, and educational opportunities to strengthen people-to-people connections and maintain its appeal as a reliable partner. The ongoing Bhutan-India Friendship Motor Rally fosters people-to-people connections and showcases India's presence in the region.
  5. Multilateral Partnerships: India can involve Bhutan in regional initiatives like the Indo-Pacific Economic Corridor and Quad, providing Bhutan a platform to voice its concerns and secure diplomatic support against undue Chinese pressure.

Navigating China's growing presence in Bhutan demands a proactive and multi-pronged approach from India. By focusing on economic re-engagement, border resolution, enhanced security cooperation, and continued cultural ties, India can safeguard its security interests and secure a future where Bhutan remains a valued strategic partner, not a geopolitical pawn. 

Subjects : Polity
Only Students can submit Answer.