Mains Daily Question
Oct. 20, 2023

Q1. “Ban on single-use plastic is a significant step but not a complete solution to curb plastic pollution”. Comment. (10M/150W)

Model Answer

Approach

Introduction

We can introduce the answer either by explaining plastic pollution or when India decided to ban SUPs. We can also start by highlighting the contribution of SUPs to overall plastic pollution.

Body

Since the directive is to comment, we first have to explain the statement, i.e., why is the step of banning SUPs is effective and what are its limitations. Then, we will start additional measures needed to combat plastic pollution.

Conclusion

Here we can conclude either by summarizing the arguments of body section

 

Answer

Plastic pollution refers to the accumulation of plastic waste in the environment, leading to negative impacts on ecosystems, wildlife, human health, and overall ecological balance. In lieu of combating plastic pollution, India launched in 2018 the "Plastic Waste-Free India" campaign to eliminate single-use plastics.

 

Rationale behind the banning of SUPs

  • Limiting SUPs Consumption: The move would help to limit the widespread consumption of plastic, of which Single-Use Plastics (SUPs) are an important segment.
    • For example, the city of Bengaluru, India, implemented a ban on single-use plastics in 2016, which led to a significant reduction in plastic waste generation.
  • Mitigating Microplastic Generation: Many single-use plastics degrade into microplastics, tiny particles that can infiltrate various ecosystems.
  • To Mitigate Climate Change and Control GHG emissions: The production of SUP (using fossil fuels) releases significant amounts of greenhouse gases (GHGs), like carbon dioxide. Banning SUPs can indirectly reduce the demand for fossil fuels and mitigate GHG emissions, which are a major driver of climate change.
    • For example, the production of plastic bags from fossil fuels releases approximately 6 kg of carbon dioxide per kg of plastic.
  • India’s Climate Target: India's INDC aims to reduce the carbon intensity of its GDP by 33-35% by 2030. A ban on SUPs, thus, helps transition to environmentally friendly alternatives.
  • Preserving Marine Ecosystems: Single-use plastics often end up in oceans and water bodies, posing a grave threat to marine life.
    • For example, the "Beat Plastic Pollution" campaign in Mumbai, India, organized beach clean-ups to raise awareness about the harmful impact of single-use plastics on marine ecosystems.
  • Enhancing Aesthetic Appeal: Banning single-use plastics contributes to cleaner landscapes, cities, and natural areas.
    • For example, McLeod Ganj in Himachal Pradesh banned single-use plastics in 2018 which resulted in cleaner streets, improved tourism experiences, and a positive visual impact on the town's natural beauty.

 

Banning of SUPs - not a complete solution (Students can use mind map to show this)

  • Lack of Cheap Alternatives: The availability of cheap alternatives to cater to the demand for SUPs’ banned products is a critical challenge as India generates 26000 tons of plastic waste every day, and it would be difficult to replace it.
  • Lack of Specific Advisory: India has not yet issued any advisory to stop the use of Single plastics (SUPs), and no penalties have been imposed following the ban.
  • Lack of Ability: The ban on SUPs impacts the most vulnerable segments, especially the small and medium enterprises (SMEs) of the plastic industry.

 

Additional Measures Needed

  • Promote Recycling and the Circular Economy: Implement and strengthen recycling programs, ensuring efficient collection, segregation, and recycling of plastic waste.
    • For example, the city of Pune, Maharashtra, has implemented a successful door-to-door plastic waste collection system.
  • Eco-Friendly Packaging: Encourage industries to adopt sustainable packaging practices, such as using minimal packaging, reusable containers, and biodegradable materials.
    • For example, the brand "Paper Boat" in India packages its beverages in Tetra Paks, which are made from renewable materials and are recyclable.
  • Innovative Solutions: Invest in research and development of innovative technologies and materials that can replace plastics or make them more biodegradable.
    • For example, the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Madras has developed edible cutlery made from millets and rice, providing an innovative and eco-friendly alternative to single- use plastic cutlery.
  • Waste Management Infrastructure: Invest in efficient waste management systems, including proper collection, segregation, and recycling facilities.
    • For example, the "Clean Kerala Company" in Kerala has implemented a decentralized waste management system, including organic waste composting units and plastic shredding machines.

 

In essence, while banning single-use plastic items is an important step towards tackling plastic pollution, it's just one piece of the puzzle. A comprehensive solution involves a combination of regulatory measures, public awareness campaigns, sustainable practices, waste management improvements, innovation, and international cooperation to address the full spectrum of challenges posed by plastic pollution.

Subjects : Environment
Only Students can submit Answer.