Mains Daily Question
July 20, 2023

Explore the feasibility of introducing Universal Basic Income in a country with a large informal economy like India.

Model Answer

Approach:

Introduction: Define Universal Basic Income and talk about the feasibility of implementing it in brief.

Body: Explain why it is difficult to implement UBI in India. Highlight steps that can be taken to mitigate the challenges of implementing UBI.

Conclusion: Give an adequate way forward describing how Universal Basic Income can culminate into reality.

 

Answer:

Universal Basic Income (UBI) is a policy concept that involves providing a regular and unconditional cash payment to all individuals within a given population, regardless of their income, employment status, or wealth. The objective of UBI is to ensure that every citizen has a minimum level of income to cover their basic needs, such as food, shelter, and healthcare, thereby reducing poverty and economic inequality.

 

Implementing UBI in India will be difficult:

 

  1. Informal Economy Size: India's informal economy is substantial, with a large portion of the population engaged in unregulated or cash-based activities. Estimates vary, but it is believed that around 80-90% of the total workforce is part of the informal sector.

 

  1. Financial Burden: India's population is over 1.4 billion, and providing a meaningful UBI to every citizen could impose a significant financial burden on the government. Funding a UBI would require a robust taxation system and sound fiscal management.

 

  1. Targeting the Vulnerable: UBI aims to provide a safety net for the most vulnerable in society, but in a country as diverse as India, ensuring accurate targeting and preventing misuse of funds would be critical and would require sophisticated administrative systems and data infrastructure.

 

  1. Impact on Labor Market: Critics argue that UBI could disincentivize people from seeking formal employment or discourage them from participating in the formal economy. In India, where informal labour is already prevalent, this concern becomes even more significant. Designing UBI in a way that complements, rather than replaces, formal employment opportunities would be crucial.

 

  1. Regional Disparities: India experiences considerable economic disparities between different states and regions. A one-size-fits-all approach to UBI may not be appropriate. Tailoring the UBI amount to regional cost-of-living and economic conditions could help address this issue.

 

  1. Cost of Living Variation: The cost of living varies significantly across different parts of India. A fixed UBI amount may not adequately support individuals in high-cost regions while potentially being excessive in low-cost regions. Taking regional variations into account would be essential for effective implementation.

 

  1. Administrative Infrastructure: Implementing a UBI program in a country of India's size and complexity would require a robust administrative infrastructure, including a reliable identification system, banking facilities, and mechanisms to prevent fraud and corruption.

 

  1. Public Acceptance: The success of UBI also depends on public acceptance and understanding of the program's objectives. Educating the population about the benefits and potential trade-offs of UBI including doing away with the other regular subsidies and benefits, would be crucial to garnering support.

 

Specific measures to mitigate the challenges of introducing Universal Basic Income (UBI):

 

  1. Financial Inclusion Initiatives:
  • Launch the "Jan Dhan 2.0" program to provide free bank accounts to all informal workers, making it easier for them to receive UBI payments.
  • Partner with mobile network operators to offer no-cost or low-cost mobile banking services to enable digital transactions in rural and remote areas.

 

  1. Integration with Formal Economy:
  • Establish UBI-linked skill development centres in urban and rural areas to equip informal workers with relevant skills for formal employment opportunities.
  • Offer tax incentives to small and medium-sized enterprises that employ a certain percentage of former informal workers, encouraging the creation of formal jobs.

 

  1. Gradual Implementation:
  • Begin with pilot UBI programs in select districts or states with high concentrations of informal workers to assess the program's impact on poverty and the economy.
  • Set up a dedicated task force to evaluate the pilot results and make data-driven decisions before expanding the UBI program nationally.

 

  1. Means Testing and Targeting:
  • Develop a comprehensive database of informal workers using Aadhaar (unique identification) and other relevant data to assess eligibility for UBI.
  • Utilize machine learning algorithms to identify vulnerable populations and exclude those who are relatively well-off from the UBI program.

 

 

Introducing Universal Basic Income requires careful consideration of the country's unique economic and social context. Piloting small-scale UBI experiments in specific regions or demographics could provide valuable insights and data to evaluate its feasibility and impact before implementing it nationwide. Ultimately, UBI should be seen as one component of a broader social and economic policy framework aimed at fostering sustainable development and reducing poverty in India.

Subjects : Current Affairs
Only Students can submit Answer.