Mains Daily Question
Dec. 27, 2023
Q.1) “A growing sense of regionalism may seriously threaten India's unity and integrity”. Critically examine. (10M/150W)
Approach to the answer: Understanding and structuring the answer: Question talks about regionalism and its linkages with India’s unity and integrity. In the first part, mention how regionalism can pose a major challenge to India’s unity and integrity. In the second part, mention the positive impacts of regionalism. Introduction: Type 1: Start by defining regionalism; or Type 2: Start with brief current affair background related to regionalism Body: Heading 1: How regionalism threaten India’s unity and integrity: Mention challenges to Indian society due to regionalism Heading 2: Positive of regionalism: Write benefits of regionalism For value addition, you can mention a way forward, and a case study (in a diagrammatic form). Conclusion: Type 1: Give a futuristic conclusion as regionalism should be shaped to secure India’s unity and integrity. Type 2: Give way ahead by giving a balanced view followed by a positive conclusion. |
Answer: Regionalism is a political ideology that focuses on the interests of a particular region, group of regions or other subnational entity. It is driven by the conscientiousness of loyalty to a distinct region with a homogenous population in terms of cultural, social, political, economic aspiration, or ethnicity.
Regionalism can pose a threat to India’s unity and integrity in the following ways: |
- Disrupting national identity: Regionalism can lead to the fragmentation of the national identity, making it difficult for people to identify with a single unified Indian identity.
- For example, in India people identify themselves based on their states like a Tamilian, a Bengali, a Bihari etc, more than the identity of an ‘Indian’.
- Demands for separatism: In some cases, regionalism can escalate into demands for separatism, which can seriously threaten India's unity and integrity.
- For example, demands for a separate Khalistan state.
- Ethnic tensions: Regionalism can cause tensions between different ethnic groups, leading to conflicts and violence, as seen in some separatist movements in states.
- For example, ethnic tensions in Northeast India.
- Economic disparities: Regionalism can create economic disparities between different regions, leading to feelings of neglect and resentment among people in less developed regions.
Benefits of regionalism: |
- Strengthening democracy: Regionalism leads to the rise of regional parties which prevents the monopolization of one single political party.
- For example, the rise of regional parties DMK, BSP, AAP, Trinamool congress etc.
- Economic development: Regionalism can help promote economic development by encouraging investment in less developed regions. This can lead to the creation of jobs and the growth of local industries, which can contribute to the overall growth of the country's economy.
- For example, the creation of a separate state of Chhattisgarh has promoted their development (SGDP growing by 8%).
- Improved governance: Regionalism can encourage the devolution of power from the central government to local authorities, which can lead to more efficient and effective governance.
- For example, Rise of DMK led to effective implementation of government schemes like the Mid-day meal scheme.
- Fostering competitive federalism: Regionalism may induce competition among people of a region and propel them to do better to improve the status of their region.
- For example, regionalism may foster competition among states regarding resources, setting up of industries, infrastructural facilities, etc.
- Preservation of local culture: Regionalism can help preserve local cultures and traditions, which are often unique and valuable. It can also promote the use of local languages and dialects, which might otherwise be lost or marginalized.
- For example, Tamil Nadu regional parties work for securing its Dravidian identities like Tamil language
While growing regionalism in India can pose challenges to national unity and integrity, it is crucial to critically evaluate its impact. Balancing regional aspirations with the broader goals of national integration, addressing economic disparities, and promoting inclusive development are essential to ensure that regionalism does not threaten the unity and integrity of the country. Effective governance, inclusive policies, and sustained efforts towards national integration are key in managing the potential negative consequences of regionalism.